11 Best Tufted Ottoman Cushions Creators Love

A Nostalgic Touch: Why Tufted Ottoman Cushions Make Every Room Feel Like Home

Do you remember those cozy afternoons at your grandmother’s house, feet up on her old ottoman, flipping through magazines or nibbling on homemade cookies? For me, tufted ottoman cushions always bring back that sense of comfort and belonging. There’s something about the soft, inviting texture and classic button-tufting that instantly makes a space feel more welcoming. Maybe it’s the way they blend vintage charm with modern style, but I can’t help but love how they transform any living room, reading nook, or bedroom corner.

Lately, I’ve noticed some of the top home decor YouTubers—think Alexandra Gater, Lone Fox, and The Sorry Girls—rave about their favorite tufted ottoman cushions. Each has their own style, yet they all agree: nothing beats the perfect tufted cushion for tying a space together. I’ve tested, researched, and watched just about every video to round up the 11 best tufted ottoman cushions that creators genuinely love—and that will make your home feel just as special.

Let’s jump right in!

What Makes a Tufted Ottoman Cushion Truly Great?

Before you fall in love with a pretty photo (I’ve been there!), let’s talk about what sets the best tufted ottoman cushions apart.

What to Look For in a Tufted Ottoman Cushion

Materials: Think soft velvet, durable linen, or breathable cotton. Plush fabrics are perfect for lounging, while sturdy weaves hold up to busy households.
Filling: High-density foam keeps its shape and feels supportive. Polyfill is softer but flattens quicker.
Size & Shape: Measure your ottoman! Square, round, or rectangular—make sure your cushion fits snugly.
Color Palette: Neutrals for timeless appeal; bold colors for a statement. Match or contrast with your decor.
Details: Deep tufting, piped edges, or decorative buttons add character.
Washability: Removable covers are a lifesaver for spills and snacks (especially if you have kids or pets).

1. West Elm Tufted Velvet Ottoman Cushion

Recommended by: Alexandra Gater

I first spotted this beauty in Alexandra’s “Apartment Makeover” series. She called it her “secret weapon” for elevating any room without much effort.

Materials: Luxe velvet in shades like Blush, Emerald, and Iron Gray
Dimensions: 24″ round x 4″ thick
Features: Hand-tufted with deep button detail, piped edge; dense foam core for support
Why I Love It: The velvet feels buttery soft and looks expensive (even if you’re on a budget). The color range is versatile—Blush warms up neutrals, while Emerald offers that rich pop.
Personal Note: Mine’s lasted through endless feet-up movie nights and even a wine spill (thankfully, it wiped right off).

Practical tip: Velvet is surprisingly easy to spot-clean with a damp cloth. Just don’t use harsh chemicals.

2. Pottery Barn Chunky Woven Tufted Cushion

Recommended by: The Sorry Girls

DIY queens Kelsey and Becky swear by this cushion for its texture and durability. It’s their go-to for layering boho vibes into almost any setup.

Materials: Thick woven cotton with subtle tonal variations
Dimensions: 30″ x 16″ rectangle
Features: Hand-tufted surface; extra-plush polyfill insert; removable cover with zipper
Why I Love It: The chunky weave adds tactile interest—perfect for a farmhouse or eclectic look. It’s super comfy for sitting on the floor during game nights.
Personal Note: I used it as a bench cushion when guests came over—it held up beautifully.

Practical tip: The cover is machine washable (cold cycle), so don’t stress about muddy paws or snack crumbs.

3. Anthropologie Tufted Nouveau Ottoman Cushion

Recommended by: Lone Fox

Drew Scott from Lone Fox is all about mixing classic and modern. He highlighted this cushion in his “Small Space Styling” video and I immediately understood why.

Materials: Velvet with metallic thread accents
Dimensions: 22″ round x 5″ thick
Features: Luxe button-tufting; gold piping around the edges; thick foam for extra height
Why I Love It: The metallic threads subtly catch the light—so elegant. It’s both glam and understated.
Personal Note: I get constant compliments whenever friends visit (“Where did you get that ottoman?!”).

Practical tip: Look for these on sale around holidays—they’re often marked down!

4. CB2 Channel Tufted Ottoman Cushion

Recommended by: Studio McGee

Shea McGee’s signature look is clean and tailored, and this CB2 cushion fits perfectly into her style.

Materials: Performance velvet (stain-resistant)
Dimensions: 28″ x 18″ x 4″
Features: Unique channel-tufting (not buttons); supportive foam insert; firm structure holds its shape
Why I Love It: Channel tufting feels modern and sophisticated. The performance velvet resists stains—ideal for high-traffic living rooms.
Personal Note: We use ours daily as an extra seat (somehow it never flattens out).

Practical tip: If you’re tired of traditional button-tufting, channel tufting is a fresh update.

5. Urban Outfitters Tufted Corduroy Floor Cushion

Recommended by: Mr. Kate

Mr. Kate is the queen of quirky cool, and her pick doesn’t disappoint.

Materials: Ribbed corduroy in muted jewel tones
Dimensions: 26″ square x 5″ thick
Features: Deep square tufting; plush polyfill; stitched handle for easy moving
Why I Love It: The corduroy feels retro in the best way—think ‘70s lounge chic. It’s heavy enough to stay put but light enough to move from room to room.
Personal Note: My dog claimed this cushion as her throne the first day it arrived.

Practical tip: These stack nicely if you need extra floor seating for guests or kids’ sleepovers.

6. Society6 Artist Tufted Floor Pillow

Recommended by: Hermione Chantal

If you want your decor to have personality, Society6 is the place. Hermione Chantal loves their artist-designed options.

Materials: Soft polyester with original printed artwork
Dimensions: 26″ round x 6″ thick
Features: All-over prints from independent artists; button-tufted center; machine washable cover
Why I Love It: No one else will have your exact cushion—there are thousands of designs! From florals to abstracts, you’ll find something that fits your vibe.
Personal Note: I picked a botanical print for spring—it brightens up my space instantly.

Practical tip: Order early if you want a matching set; artist collections change often.

7. Target Threshold™ Tufted Floor Cushion

Recommended by: XO MaCenna

Affordable, stylish, and easy to find—I see why XO MaCenna features this Target gem in her room makeovers.

Materials: Textured woven cotton; available in cream, olive green, or blush pink
Dimensions: 24″ square x 4″ thick
Features: Button-tufting; piped edges; plush polyfill insert
Why I Love It: It’s cute enough for Instagram but tough enough for everyday use. The neutral shades work well in just about any room.
Personal Note: I bought two—one for my living room, one for my daughter’s play area.

Practical tip: Keep an eye on seasonal releases—Threshold often updates colors with new trends.

8. World Market Tufted Jute & Cotton Pouf Cushion

Recommended by: Liza Prideaux

British home influencer Liza Prideaux loves a natural touch in her interiors—and so do I!

Materials: Handwoven jute with soft cotton accents
Dimensions: 20″ round x 4″ thick
Features: Mixed-material texture; deep tufting; zip-off cover for easy cleaning
Why I Love It: Earthy jute brings instant warmth and texture. Perfect for beachy, boho, or rustic spaces.
Personal Note: I use mine as both an ottoman pad and extra seating on our patio.

Practical tip: Jute is durable but can feel rough—layer with a throw if you want it softer against bare skin.

9. Etsy Custom Tufted Ottoman Cushions by SewnNatural

Recommended by: DIYDanielle

If you need something totally custom (hello oddly-sized ottomans!), Etsy sellers like SewnNatural are lifesavers.

Materials: Natural linen or organic cotton; custom color choices available
Dimensions: Made-to-order (any size/shape)
Features: Hand-tufted buttons; piped edges; eco-friendly fill options available
Why I Love It: You get exactly what you want—no more compromising on fit or color! Plus, supporting independent makers feels good.
Personal Note: SewnNatural made me a long bench cushion in sage green linen—it matches my drapes perfectly.

Practical tip: Double-check measurements before ordering custom pieces to ensure a perfect fit.

10. The Company Store LoftAIRE Down Alternative Tufted Cushion

Recommended by: Clutterbug

Cass from Clutterbug loves comfort that’s easy to maintain—this down-alternative cushion checks all the boxes.

Materials: Brushed cotton twill cover; hypoallergenic LoftAIRE fill
Dimensions: 26″ square x 5″ thick
Features: Box-style tufting; double-stitch seams; machine washable cover
Why I Love It: Feels like a cloud but doesn’t trigger allergies! The cotton cover is soft but sturdy—great for busy homes.
Personal Note: We use it as a meditation cushion (my husband has back issues and says it’s perfect support).

Practical tip: Down alternative filling won’t clump as quickly as basic polyfill when washed.

11. Wayfair Gracie Oaks Alldredge Floor Pillow

Recommended by: The DIY Mommy

The DIY Mommy is always hunting for affordable yet stylish finds—her Wayfair pick is one of my favorites too.

Materials: Chenille polyester blend
Dimensions: 28″ round x 7″ thick
Features: Deep button-tufting; piped edge detail; overstuffed for loftiness
Why I Love It: The chenille fabric feels plush and inviting—almost velvety but more durable. Its generous size works well as an ottoman top or floor cushion.
Personal Note: My kids drag this from room to room—it’s become our go-to spot for reading together.

Practical tip: If you want maximum squish factor, fluff it up in the dryer on air-only setting every month or so.

How To Choose The Right Tufted Ottoman Cushion

I know—it’s easy to get lost among all these gorgeous options! Here are my tried-and-tested tips:

Size Matters

Always measure your ottoman (or bench) before buying. Oversized cushions can look sloppy if they hang over the edge; undersized ones slide around annoyingly.

Material Match

Pick a fabric that works with your lifestyle:

Velvet: Luxe look, great for low-mess homes.
Cotton/Linen: Breathable and casual.
Performance Fabrics: Best for pets/kids/spills.

Color Confidence

Go bold if you want your ottoman to stand out—or stick with neutrals for an easy match-all look. Remember: textures like corduroy or jute add depth even in neutral tones!

Filling Counts

High-density foam keeps its shape best (especially if the cushion will be sat on often). Polyfill is cushier but may flatten faster—choose depending on purpose.

Washability

Removable covers are a lifesaver. If you love white or light colors, make sure you can toss the cover in the wash!

Frequently Asked Questions About Tufted Ottoman Cushions

Can I use these cushions outdoors?

Some are suitable for covered patios (jute blends or polyester), but most aren’t weatherproof. Always check care instructions! For outdoor use, look for UV-resistant fabrics.

How do I clean tufted ottoman cushions?

Spot clean velvet or chenille with a damp cloth and mild soap. Most cotton covers zip off for machine washing—air dry to avoid shrinking! Brush off dust regularly to keep them looking fresh.

Will these cushions fit any ottoman?

Most come in standard sizes but check your measurements! For odd shapes or built-ins, custom options like those from Etsy are the way to go.

Are tufted cushions comfortable enough to sit on?

Yes! Choose thicker options (at least 4” thick) with dense foam if you’ll use them as seating. For feet-only ottomans, lighter fill works fine.

Do tufted buttons come loose over time?

Quality matters here—hand-tufted buttons hold up better than machine ones. If yours ever pops off, most can be sewn back easily.

Style & Functionality: Final Thoughts

After years of testing (and lounging!), I can confidently say that a well-chosen tufted ottoman cushion does more than just look pretty—it adds real comfort and personality to your home. Whether you want plush velvet luxury or boho woven texture, there’s an option here that fits your life perfectly.

I hope this guide helps you choose a cushion you’ll love every day—maybe even one that becomes part of your own nostalgic memories. Happy decorating!