9 Best Tufted Bench Cushions Creators Love
Did You Know Your Bench Cushion Can Totally Transform Your Space?
Have you ever sat on a bench and thought, “Wow, this could be so much cozier”? I used to think bench cushions were just for extra comfort, but after following top YouTubers like XO MaCenna and Lone Fox, I learned they’re basically the secret sauce for making any nook look Pinterest-perfect. Whether it’s a window seat, mudroom bench, or the end of your bed, a tufted bench cushion is the quickest way to add personality and plushness. But not all cushions are created equal—and creators know exactly which ones will make your home pop.
So, let’s chat about the 9 best tufted bench cushions that YouTube creators rave about. I’ll break down why these are favorites, what makes them stand out, and how they can fit into your home’s vibe. Ready? Let’s get comfy!
1. The Inside Custom Tufted Bench Cushion
Why Creators Love It
If you’ve ever watched XO MaCenna’s “Window Seat Makeover,” you’ve seen The Inside’s tufted bench cushion in action. She called it “the ultimate upgrade for any seating area.” What grabbed my attention? Their cushions are customizable in over 100 fabrics—including rich velvets, textured linens, and playful patterns.
Features & Details
- Materials: High-density foam core wrapped in poly fill for just-right softness.
- Colors & Fabrics: Choose from blush velvet, emerald green linen, or funky leopard print (honestly, I’m torn between the blush and emerald).
- Dimensions: Made-to-order; fits benches from 36″ to 72″ long.
- Style: Deep tufting with piped edges—think classic with a modern twist.
Personal Take
I ordered the emerald velvet for my entryway bench. The color is lush and the tufting adds a vintage vibe. Sitting on it feels supportive yet cloud-like.
Value Tip
If you want your bench cushion to be the focal point, go bold with fabric. The Inside lets you order swatches ($2 each) before committing.
2. Pottery Barn Tufted Performance Velvet Bench Cushion
Why Creators Love It
Pottery Barn is always popping up on DIY channels for good reason: their bench cushions last forever. Lone Fox swears by their performance velvet because it survives spills, pets, and everyday wear.
Features & Details
- Materials: Performance velvet (stain-resistant), recycled-poly fill.
- Colors: Almost every neutral you can imagine—Ivory, Charcoal, Navy.
- Dimensions: Standard sizes from 36″x16″ up to 60″x20″.
- Style: Button tufting with clean edges—simple, elegant, timeless.
Personal Take
When I had a puppy phase (messy paws everywhere!), this cushion was a lifesaver. Spilled coffee? Wipes right off.
Value Tip
If durability and easy cleaning matter most, stick with performance fabrics like velvet or Sunbrella.
3. West Elm Box Tufted Bench Cushion
Why Creators Love It
West Elm’s box tufted design gets tons of love on Studio McGee’s channel for its crisp lines and mid-century look. If you like structured and tailored vibes, this is your cushion.
Features & Details
- Materials: Eco-friendly foam core; upholstery-grade linen or twill.
- Colors: Slate Blue, Oatmeal, Olive.
- Dimensions: 48″x16″, 60″x20″.
- Style: Box tufting (no buttons), squared-off piping—very chic.
Personal Take
The Oatmeal linen feels textured but not scratchy. It’s firm enough for extra seating during parties but still comfy for reading.
Value Tip
Measure your bench before buying! West Elm’s sizes are pretty exact; a snug fit looks best.
4. Society6 Tufted Bench Cushion
Why Creators Love It
Society6 turns your bench into an art piece. Creators like Mr. Kate recommend their cushions for unique patterns—think watercolor florals, abstract shapes, even illustrated cats.
Features & Details
- Materials: Polyester fleece top with foam fill; non-slip bottom.
- Colors/Designs: Hundreds of artist-designed prints—from pastel rainbows to moody botanicals.
- Dimensions: 44″x15″, fits most standard benches.
- Style: Light tufting; edge piping for a finished look.
Personal Take
I got the “Galaxy Swirl” design for my daughter’s playroom. It adds instant personality and is surprisingly sturdy.
Value Tip
If you want your cushion to double as decor, choose Society6—there’s a print for every taste.
5. Ballard Designs Tufted Sunbrella Bench Cushion
Why Creators Love It
Outdoor DIYers like Garden Answer love Ballard’s Sunbrella cushions for patios and porches—they’re weatherproof but look just as stylish indoors.
Features & Details
- Materials: Sunbrella acrylic (UV/fade/mildew resistant), quick-dry foam.
- Colors: Navy Stripe, Canvas White, Black.
- Dimensions: Custom sizes from 36″ up to 96″ long.
- Style: Classic button tufting; tailored corners.
Personal Take
I used one on my covered porch and it survived two summers without fading. Even after rainstorms, it dried quickly and kept its shape.
Value Tip
If you need a cushion for both inside and outside use, Sunbrella is worth every penny.
6. Etsy Handmade Tufted Bench Cushion by HomeOfWool
Why Creators Love It
HomeOfWool is a darling of natural-living YouTube channels like Farmhouse on Boone. Their handcrafted wool cushions are hypoallergenic and sustainable—a win for eco-minded decorators.
Features & Details
- Materials: 100% natural wool fill, organic cotton or linen cover.
- Colors: Cream, Gray, Olive Green.
- Dimensions: Custom; any size you want!
- Style: Deep hand-tufting with chunky yarn ties—cozy cottage vibes.
Personal Take
The wool fill feels warm in winter and cool in summer. Plus, it’s naturally dust-mite resistant (allergy relief!).
Value Tip
If you have sensitive skin or want earth-friendly decor, handmade wool cushions are unbeatable.
7. CB2 Channel Tufted Bench Cushion
Why Creators Love It
CB2’s channel tufted design shows up in almost every minimalist makeover video I watch. The horizontal lines give a sleek, contemporary feel—and the velvet options are drool-worthy.
Features & Details
- Materials: Poly foam fill; velvet or boucle fabric.
- Colors: Emerald Green, Rust, Ivory Boucle.
- Dimensions: 48″x18″, 60″x20″.
- Style: Channel tufting (no buttons); squared corners for a modern edge.
Personal Take
I bought the rust velvet for my office window seat. The texture catches the light beautifully—so Instagrammable.
Value Tip
For a modern look that’s still comfy, channel tufting is more supportive than traditional button tufting.
8. Wayfair Zipcode Design Tufted Bench Cushion
Why Creators Love It
Wayfair’s Zipcode Design is all over budget-friendly home tours—creators love the variety and affordability. These cushions come in playful colors and patterns without breaking the bank.
Features & Details
- Materials: Polyester microfiber cover; poly fiber core.
- Colors/Designs: Mustard Yellow, Teal Blue, Geometric Gray.
- Dimensions: 42″x14″, 48″x16″.
- Style: Button tufting; piped edges for structure.
Personal Take
I ordered two in Mustard Yellow for my mudroom bench. They’re bright and cheerful—and easy to spot clean after muddy boots.
Value Tip
Need a quick decor refresh on a budget? Wayfair is an easy go-to.
9. Urban Outfitters Margot Velvet Tufted Bench Cushion
Why Creators Love It
Urban Outfitters is a favorite among boho-loving YouTubers like Lone Fox for its playful colors and plush textures. The Margot Velvet cushion is basically Pinterest IRL—soft, jewel-toned velvet with deep tufting.
Features & Details
- Materials: Velvet polyester shell; plush poly fill.
- Colors: Sage Green, Rose Pink, Goldenrod.
- Dimensions: 40″x16″ (fits most entryway benches).
- Style: Diamond tufting with slightly rounded corners—soft and inviting.
Personal Take
I added the sage green to my reading nook bench. It’s squishy-soft and makes the space feel lux but lived-in.
Value Tip
For small benches or window seats where you want max comfort and color impact, Margot Velvet is a winner.
How to Pick Your Perfect Tufted Bench Cushion
Shopping for a bench cushion can get overwhelming—so many styles! Here’s how I narrow it down:
1. Size First
Always measure your bench before shopping. Cushions look best when they fit snugly (not oversized or undersized). Check both length and depth!
2. Material Matters
If you have kids or pets (or just spill coffee a lot), performance fabrics like velvet or Sunbrella make cleanup easy. For allergy-prone folks or eco-conscious homes, go natural with wool or organic cotton.
3. Style & Tufting Type
Button tufting gives a traditional look; channel or box tufting is more modern. Think about your home’s vibe—do you want cozy cottage or sleek city chic?
4. Color Palette
Neutral tones blend with any decor but don’t be afraid of bold colors or prints if you want your bench to pop! Swatches help if you’re torn between options.
5. Comfort Level
Some cushions are plush and thick; others are firmer for extra seating support. Decide if your bench is mostly decorative or needs to handle daily use.
FAQ: Everything You Need to Know Before Buying
Q: How do I clean my tufted bench cushion?
Most performance fabrics wipe clean with damp cloths; removable covers can be machine-washed (always check tags!). Wool or linen should be spot-cleaned with mild soap.
Q: Will my cushion flatten over time?
Higher-density foam and quality poly fill keep their shape longer—even after daily use. Rotate cushions every few months to keep wear even.
Q: Can I use indoor cushions outside?
Only if they’re made with outdoor fabrics like Sunbrella! Otherwise, moisture will ruin them quickly.
Q: What if I have an odd-sized bench?
Custom options from The Inside, Ballard Designs, and Etsy makers are perfect for unique shapes or sizes. Just send your measurements!
Q: How do I style my bench once I have the cushion?
Layer with throw pillows in contrasting colors/textures or add a cozy blanket for extra personality!
Final Thoughts: Make Your Bench Work Harder and Look Better!
A tufted bench cushion isn’t just about comfort—it’s about turning a simple seat into a highlight of your home. Whether you want luxe velvet (hello Urban Outfitters!), hard-wearing outdoor fabric (thanks Ballard Designs), or an artsy conversation piece (Society6 anyone?), there’s something here for every taste and budget.
If you’re like me—a sucker for cozy corners and stylish details—these picks will totally change how you use your space. So next time you flop onto your bench with a cup of tea, know you’ve made a choice creators would totally approve of!
Happy decorating—and don’t forget to measure twice before ordering!